Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Sign In  |  Sign up
Your Cart (0)
Best Deals
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > Hindu > Between Jerusalem and Benares: Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism
Subscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Between Jerusalem and Benares: Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism
Between Jerusalem and Benares: Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism
Description

Preface

When we first went from Jerusalem to Benares, some twenty years ago, my wife and I met an old man on the Sarnath bus. Not knowing us, not knowing whence we had arrived, he began to speak to us in hushed tones, as if conveying a great secret. He loved Benares, and he told us: “There are two cities in the world that are truly alike, two ancient sisters—Jerusalem and Benares." He was thinking, surely, about a certain kind of continuous passion for an experience we sometimes call "holy,” manifest in a single place; and he may also have meant some- thing more than this, something connected to the varied and often paradoxical relations between this ”holiness" or "otherness" and the life of a civilization unfolding around it. This book is devoted to exploring that venerable Banarsi's proposition.

The proposition is by no means axiomatic, and this is the first book that has thought it worthy of serious notice. Do the two cultures share anything basic? Is the comparison worth pursuing? At first glance, from the vantage point of Jerusalem, India seems to be immersed in what the Jews call avodah zarah, “alien worship," that is, a form of idolatry. (This has also been a prevalent Islamic perspective on Indian religion, as centuries of Muslim iconoclasm in India have shown.) The panoply of temples, with their stone or metal images; the richly sensuous modes of worship; the apparent proximity of god and man; the potential manifestations of the divine in any place or thing; the readiness of the mystic to proclaim, so 'ham asmi, "I am God"—all these are conducive to this rather hostile view. From Benares, on the other hand, Jerusalem may seem stubbornly, even perversely, fixated in a severely nirguna mode. The Jews insist on God’s unity and transcendence and claim, at least, to deny him representation——although, for many Hindus, the Biblical use of language to speak of God as having thoughts, intentions, actions, attributes, not to mention metaphors or figures such as “a strong hand and mighty arm," is not qualitatively different from actual representation in visual images. Even metaphoric conceptualization fractures the infinite wholeness of the Absolute. Philosophic Hinduism is perfectly aware of this issue: Sankara is said to have prayed on his deathbed for forgiveness (from whom?) for having worshipped God in his partial manifestations, in temples and mental images, with human language. Such limitations are no more than painful concessions to our weakness. This being so, the Hindu might well ask, why all the fuss about symbolization, why the monotheistic horror of the visible?

This first, impressionistic line of division could be formulated as a hypothesis: Is it true that the Jews worship a saguna god—a deity endowed with attributes—who cannot be symbolized, while Hindus worship a nirguna Absolute, without attributes, who can? But much more than the issue of symbolism is at stake. There are questions here of epistemology, of the relation to sacred texts and their explication, of the social and cultural construction of the self, of ethical philosophy, and of basic cultural intuitions that, however much they transform themselves over time, remain distinct. Let me give two examples from one year in Jerusalem. When our seminar on enigmas invited several Bible scholars to discuss the opening chapters of Genesis, and they proceeded to do so with their customary vigor and concern for the singular truth of the text, my Hindu colleague, V. Narayana Rao, whispered to me: "If I have to be reborn, I have only one request—let it not be into a monotheistic religion." Factuality is not, perhaps, the dominant Hindu interpretative mode for metaphysical utterance. Later he at- tended a lecture by my colleague Moshe Idel, who strove to prove, in the face of much skepticism, that the cherubim in the Second Temple carried a powerful erotic symbolism of male and female hypostases uniting within the godhead. Discussion was heated, and, for obvious reasons, the thesis had to be painfully and very meticulously argued. At its conclusion, my Hindu friend remarked: "So much effort to establish what should be taken for granted!"

Are Benares and Jerusalem really part of the same world? The possibility of communication suggests that the unlikely answer may, after all, be yes. Perhaps, in the end, comparison is impossible: Cultures live out their peculiarly organic lives, and it is usually all we can do to understand a little of even one of them, on its own terms. Yet without comparison, thought itself is probably impossible, and neither taxonomy nor history could exist. Moreover, the fact of cross- cultural resonances is established by experience. I teach Sanskrit and Tamil in Jerusalem. Each year I am amazed anew at the hunger for knowledge about India that animates a select group of young Israeli students. Many of my best students come to me from the study of Kabbalah; they seem to understand easily, intuitively, the inner world of Indian texts. Bhakti religion, in particular, perhaps partly because of my own affinities, awakens their response. Some find in India a vision of the repressed Idel of their own culture. Some seek relief from their own in the exotic; the self defines itself only in relation to another, real or imagined. A few have come to me from the communities of Indian jews, with their own intimate experience and personal or family memories of India. These same students will also draw in the boundaries, the profound and evident contrasts, between Benares and Jerusalem.

The essays in this volume open a discussion, long overdue. Some trace linkages rooted in actual contact, borrowed elements, the residue of historical ties. The anthropology of India’s Jews presents a case of unconscious symbiosis and acculturation as well as powerful continuities with the imported Jewish past. The European romance of Jewish Indologists points to one type of charmed (and problematic) relations. The essays here constitute a fertile beginning. Whatever the similarities, the shared themes and tensions, this is no simple enterprise. Ultimately, it is less a matter of making comparisons, always partial and often frustrating, than of a certain kind of listening. The challenge is to hear the echoes that connect, however tenuously, two ancient civilizations, each richly endowed with experience of God and of the world, and not entirely without a history of intellectual, linguistic, and material interaction. To study them together is to' provoke the overtones or resonances, dhvani, that—so Hindu poets tell us—are the vehicle of truth.

Back of the Book

 

Between Jerusalem and Benares
Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism

Hananya

“What I like best about this book is simply that it exists.”

-Daniel Gold. Cornell University

This book stands at the crossroads between Jerusalem and Benares and opens a long awaited conversation between two ancient religious traditions. It represents the first serious studies to take seriously the cross-cultural resonances among the Judaic and Hindu traditions.

The essays in the first part of the volume explore the historical connections and influence of borrowed elements and the adaptation of Jewish Indian communities to Hindu culture. The essays in the second part focus primarily on resonances between particular conceptual complexes and practices in the two traditions, including comparative analyses of representations of Veda and Torah. Legal formulations of dharma and halakhah, and conceptions of union with the Divine in Hindu Tantra and Kabbalah.

 

Contents

 

  Acknowledgments ix
  Preface xi
  David Shulman  
1 Introduction: Judaism and Hinduism: Cultural Resonances 1
  Hananya Goodman  
2 The Love and Hate of Hinduism in the Work of Jewish Scholars 15
  Wendy Doniger  
 
PART ONE
Historical Encounters
 
3 Lexical Borrowings in Biblical Hebrew from Indian Languages as Carriers of Ideas and Technical Concepts 25
  Chaim Rabin  
4 Abraham and the Upanishads 33
  David Flusser  
5 Between Jews and Greeks: The Indian Model 41
  Francis Schmidt  
6 A Hindu Response to the Written Torah 55
  D. Dennis Hudson  
7 Yom Kippur: The Festival of Closing the Doors 85
  Shalva Weil  
 
Cultural Resonances
 
8 Veda and Torah: The Word Embodied in Scripture 103
  Barbara A. Holdrege  
9 From Dharma to Law 181
  Bernard S. Jackson  
10 Union and Unity in Hindu Tantrism 195
  Elizabeth Chalier— Visuvalingam  
11 Union and Unity in Kabbalah 223
  Charles Mopsik  
12 Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and Sri Aurobindo: Towards a Comparison 243
  Margaret Chatterjee  
  Contributors 267
  Notes 269
  Index 339

Sample Pages



Between Jerusalem and Benares: Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism

Item Code:
IHL511
Cover:
Hardcover
Edition:
1997
ISBN:
8170305225
Language:
English
Size:
8.8 inch X 5.8 inch
Pages:
344
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 520 gms
Price:
$32.50   Shipping Free
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Between Jerusalem and Benares: Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 7020 times since 8th Oct, 2015

Preface

When we first went from Jerusalem to Benares, some twenty years ago, my wife and I met an old man on the Sarnath bus. Not knowing us, not knowing whence we had arrived, he began to speak to us in hushed tones, as if conveying a great secret. He loved Benares, and he told us: “There are two cities in the world that are truly alike, two ancient sisters—Jerusalem and Benares." He was thinking, surely, about a certain kind of continuous passion for an experience we sometimes call "holy,” manifest in a single place; and he may also have meant some- thing more than this, something connected to the varied and often paradoxical relations between this ”holiness" or "otherness" and the life of a civilization unfolding around it. This book is devoted to exploring that venerable Banarsi's proposition.

The proposition is by no means axiomatic, and this is the first book that has thought it worthy of serious notice. Do the two cultures share anything basic? Is the comparison worth pursuing? At first glance, from the vantage point of Jerusalem, India seems to be immersed in what the Jews call avodah zarah, “alien worship," that is, a form of idolatry. (This has also been a prevalent Islamic perspective on Indian religion, as centuries of Muslim iconoclasm in India have shown.) The panoply of temples, with their stone or metal images; the richly sensuous modes of worship; the apparent proximity of god and man; the potential manifestations of the divine in any place or thing; the readiness of the mystic to proclaim, so 'ham asmi, "I am God"—all these are conducive to this rather hostile view. From Benares, on the other hand, Jerusalem may seem stubbornly, even perversely, fixated in a severely nirguna mode. The Jews insist on God’s unity and transcendence and claim, at least, to deny him representation——although, for many Hindus, the Biblical use of language to speak of God as having thoughts, intentions, actions, attributes, not to mention metaphors or figures such as “a strong hand and mighty arm," is not qualitatively different from actual representation in visual images. Even metaphoric conceptualization fractures the infinite wholeness of the Absolute. Philosophic Hinduism is perfectly aware of this issue: Sankara is said to have prayed on his deathbed for forgiveness (from whom?) for having worshipped God in his partial manifestations, in temples and mental images, with human language. Such limitations are no more than painful concessions to our weakness. This being so, the Hindu might well ask, why all the fuss about symbolization, why the monotheistic horror of the visible?

This first, impressionistic line of division could be formulated as a hypothesis: Is it true that the Jews worship a saguna god—a deity endowed with attributes—who cannot be symbolized, while Hindus worship a nirguna Absolute, without attributes, who can? But much more than the issue of symbolism is at stake. There are questions here of epistemology, of the relation to sacred texts and their explication, of the social and cultural construction of the self, of ethical philosophy, and of basic cultural intuitions that, however much they transform themselves over time, remain distinct. Let me give two examples from one year in Jerusalem. When our seminar on enigmas invited several Bible scholars to discuss the opening chapters of Genesis, and they proceeded to do so with their customary vigor and concern for the singular truth of the text, my Hindu colleague, V. Narayana Rao, whispered to me: "If I have to be reborn, I have only one request—let it not be into a monotheistic religion." Factuality is not, perhaps, the dominant Hindu interpretative mode for metaphysical utterance. Later he at- tended a lecture by my colleague Moshe Idel, who strove to prove, in the face of much skepticism, that the cherubim in the Second Temple carried a powerful erotic symbolism of male and female hypostases uniting within the godhead. Discussion was heated, and, for obvious reasons, the thesis had to be painfully and very meticulously argued. At its conclusion, my Hindu friend remarked: "So much effort to establish what should be taken for granted!"

Are Benares and Jerusalem really part of the same world? The possibility of communication suggests that the unlikely answer may, after all, be yes. Perhaps, in the end, comparison is impossible: Cultures live out their peculiarly organic lives, and it is usually all we can do to understand a little of even one of them, on its own terms. Yet without comparison, thought itself is probably impossible, and neither taxonomy nor history could exist. Moreover, the fact of cross- cultural resonances is established by experience. I teach Sanskrit and Tamil in Jerusalem. Each year I am amazed anew at the hunger for knowledge about India that animates a select group of young Israeli students. Many of my best students come to me from the study of Kabbalah; they seem to understand easily, intuitively, the inner world of Indian texts. Bhakti religion, in particular, perhaps partly because of my own affinities, awakens their response. Some find in India a vision of the repressed Idel of their own culture. Some seek relief from their own in the exotic; the self defines itself only in relation to another, real or imagined. A few have come to me from the communities of Indian jews, with their own intimate experience and personal or family memories of India. These same students will also draw in the boundaries, the profound and evident contrasts, between Benares and Jerusalem.

The essays in this volume open a discussion, long overdue. Some trace linkages rooted in actual contact, borrowed elements, the residue of historical ties. The anthropology of India’s Jews presents a case of unconscious symbiosis and acculturation as well as powerful continuities with the imported Jewish past. The European romance of Jewish Indologists points to one type of charmed (and problematic) relations. The essays here constitute a fertile beginning. Whatever the similarities, the shared themes and tensions, this is no simple enterprise. Ultimately, it is less a matter of making comparisons, always partial and often frustrating, than of a certain kind of listening. The challenge is to hear the echoes that connect, however tenuously, two ancient civilizations, each richly endowed with experience of God and of the world, and not entirely without a history of intellectual, linguistic, and material interaction. To study them together is to' provoke the overtones or resonances, dhvani, that—so Hindu poets tell us—are the vehicle of truth.

Back of the Book

 

Between Jerusalem and Benares
Comparative Studies in Judaism and Hinduism

Hananya

“What I like best about this book is simply that it exists.”

-Daniel Gold. Cornell University

This book stands at the crossroads between Jerusalem and Benares and opens a long awaited conversation between two ancient religious traditions. It represents the first serious studies to take seriously the cross-cultural resonances among the Judaic and Hindu traditions.

The essays in the first part of the volume explore the historical connections and influence of borrowed elements and the adaptation of Jewish Indian communities to Hindu culture. The essays in the second part focus primarily on resonances between particular conceptual complexes and practices in the two traditions, including comparative analyses of representations of Veda and Torah. Legal formulations of dharma and halakhah, and conceptions of union with the Divine in Hindu Tantra and Kabbalah.

 

Contents

 

  Acknowledgments ix
  Preface xi
  David Shulman  
1 Introduction: Judaism and Hinduism: Cultural Resonances 1
  Hananya Goodman  
2 The Love and Hate of Hinduism in the Work of Jewish Scholars 15
  Wendy Doniger  
 
PART ONE
Historical Encounters
 
3 Lexical Borrowings in Biblical Hebrew from Indian Languages as Carriers of Ideas and Technical Concepts 25
  Chaim Rabin  
4 Abraham and the Upanishads 33
  David Flusser  
5 Between Jews and Greeks: The Indian Model 41
  Francis Schmidt  
6 A Hindu Response to the Written Torah 55
  D. Dennis Hudson  
7 Yom Kippur: The Festival of Closing the Doors 85
  Shalva Weil  
 
Cultural Resonances
 
8 Veda and Torah: The Word Embodied in Scripture 103
  Barbara A. Holdrege  
9 From Dharma to Law 181
  Bernard S. Jackson  
10 Union and Unity in Hindu Tantrism 195
  Elizabeth Chalier— Visuvalingam  
11 Union and Unity in Kabbalah 223
  Charles Mopsik  
12 Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and Sri Aurobindo: Towards a Comparison 243
  Margaret Chatterjee  
  Contributors 267
  Notes 269
  Index 339

Sample Pages



Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to Between Jerusalem and Benares: Comparative Studies in Judaism and... (Hindu | Books)

Hidden Hymns (A Comparative Study Between Judaism, Christianity, Islam and The Vedas)
by Rasamandala Das
Paperback (Edition: 2018)
Blue Lotus
Item Code: NAP115
$25.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Mystic Heart of Judaism
Item Code: NAC919
$40.00
SOLD
The Holy Name (Mysticism in Judaism)
Item Code: NAL466
$25.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Jews of India
by Dalia Ray
Hardcover (Edition: 2016)
Renaissance Publishers Pvt Ltd
Item Code: NAJ143
$90.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Life after Death in World Religions
by Harold Coward
Hardcover (Edition: 1997)
Sri Satguru Publications
Item Code: IHL182
$22.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Existence and Yoga
Item Code: IDK848
$30.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Ramakrishna and Christ or The Paradox of the Incarnation
Item Code: NAH564
$8.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
A Comparative Survey of Hindu, Christian and Jewish Mysticism
by E.M. Abrahams
Hardcover (Edition: 1995)
Sri Satguru Publications
Item Code: NAC722
$30.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Jews of Andhra Pradesh (Contesting Caste and Religion in South India)
Deal 30% Off
by Yulia Egorova
Hardcover (Edition: 2013)
Oxford University Press
Item Code: NAK113
$45.00$31.50
You save: $13.50 (30%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Emptying God: A Buddhist-Jewish-Christian Conversation
Item Code: NAC454
$30.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Dharma Laws and Law Seers of India
Item Code: NAH823
$30.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Testimonials
Your website store is a really great place to find the most wonderful books and artifacts from beautiful India. I have been traveling to India over the last 4 years and spend 3 months there each time staying with two Bengali families that I have adopted and they have taken me in with love and generosity. I love India. Thanks for doing the business that you do. I am an artist and, well, I got through I think the first 6 pages of the book store on your site and ordered almost 500 dollars in books... I'm in trouble so I don't go there too often.. haha.. Hari Om and Hare Krishna and Jai.. Thanks a lot for doing what you do.. Great !
Steven, USA
Great Website! fast, easy and interesting!
Elaine, Australia
I have purchased from you before. Excellent service. Fast shipping. Great communication.
Pauline, Australia
Have greatly enjoyed the items on your site; very good selection! Thank you!
Kulwant, USA
I received my order yesterday. Thank you very much for the fast service and quality item. I’ll be ordering from you again very soon.
Brian, USA
ALMIGHTY GOD I BLESS EXOTIC INDIA AND ALL WHO WORK THERE!!!!!
Lord Grace, Switzerland
I have enjoyed the many sanskrit boks I purchased from you, especially the books by the honorable Prof. Pushpa Dixit.
K Sarma, USA
Namaste, You are doing a great service. Namah Shivay
Bikash, Denmark
The piece i ordered is beyond beautiful!!!!! I'm very well satisfied.
Richard, USA
I make a point to thank you so much for the excellent service you and your team are providing for your clients. I am highly satisfied with the high-quality level of the books I have acquired, as well as with your effective customer-care service.
Alain Rocchi, Brazil
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2019 © Exotic India