How do we know? This seemingly simple question has aroused the interest of numerous philosophers of East and West from ancient times down to the present, and innumerable answers have been given.
Because of the wide interest in this vital question, and at the urging of Dr. J.L. Shaw of Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand an international seminar on Knowledge was organized by the Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture in Calcutta. It was hoped the seminar would help narrow the wide gap of misunderstanding this subject between modern philosophers of East and West.
Thus, from the 4th and 10th of January 1995, the seminar, titled Concept of Knowledge: East and West, was held at that Institute. Thirteen scholars from overseas and ten from India participated. A number of notable scholars also attended as observers and took part in the discussion though they did not present papers.
Five all day sessions were held in the Conference Room. After each paper was read, participants and observes discussed its contents. The present volume is a collection of twenty-one seminar papers. Two papers, one by Prof. Sylvan, the other by Prof. Lepore, who were unable to attend, have been included.
Prof. R.K. Dasgupta in his paper, Swami Vivekananda Concept of knowledge, discussed western epistemology, comparing it with Swami Vivekananda's views. The editors decided that because of the paper's relevance to the subject of the seminar it would be a fitting introduction to this volume. Therefore, it has become the Foreword.
We record our heartfelt thanks to Susan Walters and Dr. J.L. Shaw for helping us with the editorial work.
The greatly Revered Swami Lokeswaranandaji, for many years Secretary of the Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture, passed away on 31 December 1998. He was responsible for planning and conducting this seminar. This volume is a memorial to his dedicated labour.
8 March 2000
Swami Prabananda
Publisher's Note | iii |
Foreword: Swami Vivekananda's Concept of Knowledge | vii |
The Epistemological Point of View of Bhartrhair Ashok Aklujkar | 1 |
Cultural Presuppositions as Determinants in Experience: A Comparison of Some Basic Indian and Western Concepts Swami Atmarupananda | 20 |
An Epistemological study of Mysticism in Christianity and Hinduism Swami Bhajanananda | 43 |
Ramanuja's Concept of Knowledge Pandit Dinesh Chandra Bhattacharya Shastri | 66 |
Some Remarks on the Definition of Knowledge Sibajiban Bhattacharyya | 74 |
The Use of the Word Prama: Valid Cognition in Advaita Vedanta Pandit Srimohan Bhattacharyya | 83 |
Theories of Error in Indian Philosophy or Five Types of Khyati Pandit Sukhamaya Bhattacharyya | 93 |
Valid Cognition and the Truth of its Object Pandit Visvabandhu Bhattacharya | 107 |
The Concept of Realization Re-Examined Margaret Chatterjee | 119 |
Classical Yoga Philosophy and Some Issues in the Philosophy of Mind Gerald James Larson | 132 |
Epistemology from a Relativistic Point of View Henri Lauener | 152 |
Epistemology and Understanding of Language Ernest Lepore | 171 |
Confucian Knowledge: Commensurability and Alterity John Makeham | 201 |
Knowledge and Ignorance J.N. Mohanty | 212 |
Truth Vs. Workability Rehashed Karl Potter | 223 |
Knowledge, Truth and Scepticism Pranab Kumar Sen | 234 |
Knowledge: some Contemporary Problems and their Solutions from the Nyaya Perspective J.L. Shaw | 244 |
Madhyamaka on Naturalized Epistemology Mark Sideritis | 262 |
What Limits to Thought, Inquiry and Philosophy Richard Sylvan | 277 |
The Action of the subject towards the Outer World in Indian Realism Toshihiro Wada | 310 |
Patanjali's Classical Yoga: an Epistemological Emphasis Ian Whicher | 322 |
How do we know? This seemingly simple question has aroused the interest of numerous philosophers of East and West from ancient times down to the present, and innumerable answers have been given.
Because of the wide interest in this vital question, and at the urging of Dr. J.L. Shaw of Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand an international seminar on Knowledge was organized by the Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture in Calcutta. It was hoped the seminar would help narrow the wide gap of misunderstanding this subject between modern philosophers of East and West.
Thus, from the 4th and 10th of January 1995, the seminar, titled Concept of Knowledge: East and West, was held at that Institute. Thirteen scholars from overseas and ten from India participated. A number of notable scholars also attended as observers and took part in the discussion though they did not present papers.
Five all day sessions were held in the Conference Room. After each paper was read, participants and observes discussed its contents. The present volume is a collection of twenty-one seminar papers. Two papers, one by Prof. Sylvan, the other by Prof. Lepore, who were unable to attend, have been included.
Prof. R.K. Dasgupta in his paper, Swami Vivekananda Concept of knowledge, discussed western epistemology, comparing it with Swami Vivekananda's views. The editors decided that because of the paper's relevance to the subject of the seminar it would be a fitting introduction to this volume. Therefore, it has become the Foreword.
We record our heartfelt thanks to Susan Walters and Dr. J.L. Shaw for helping us with the editorial work.
The greatly Revered Swami Lokeswaranandaji, for many years Secretary of the Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture, passed away on 31 December 1998. He was responsible for planning and conducting this seminar. This volume is a memorial to his dedicated labour.
8 March 2000
Swami Prabananda
Publisher's Note | iii |
Foreword: Swami Vivekananda's Concept of Knowledge | vii |
The Epistemological Point of View of Bhartrhair Ashok Aklujkar | 1 |
Cultural Presuppositions as Determinants in Experience: A Comparison of Some Basic Indian and Western Concepts Swami Atmarupananda | 20 |
An Epistemological study of Mysticism in Christianity and Hinduism Swami Bhajanananda | 43 |
Ramanuja's Concept of Knowledge Pandit Dinesh Chandra Bhattacharya Shastri | 66 |
Some Remarks on the Definition of Knowledge Sibajiban Bhattacharyya | 74 |
The Use of the Word Prama: Valid Cognition in Advaita Vedanta Pandit Srimohan Bhattacharyya | 83 |
Theories of Error in Indian Philosophy or Five Types of Khyati Pandit Sukhamaya Bhattacharyya | 93 |
Valid Cognition and the Truth of its Object Pandit Visvabandhu Bhattacharya | 107 |
The Concept of Realization Re-Examined Margaret Chatterjee | 119 |
Classical Yoga Philosophy and Some Issues in the Philosophy of Mind Gerald James Larson | 132 |
Epistemology from a Relativistic Point of View Henri Lauener | 152 |
Epistemology and Understanding of Language Ernest Lepore | 171 |
Confucian Knowledge: Commensurability and Alterity John Makeham | 201 |
Knowledge and Ignorance J.N. Mohanty | 212 |
Truth Vs. Workability Rehashed Karl Potter | 223 |
Knowledge, Truth and Scepticism Pranab Kumar Sen | 234 |
Knowledge: some Contemporary Problems and their Solutions from the Nyaya Perspective J.L. Shaw | 244 |
Madhyamaka on Naturalized Epistemology Mark Sideritis | 262 |
What Limits to Thought, Inquiry and Philosophy Richard Sylvan | 277 |
The Action of the subject towards the Outer World in Indian Realism Toshihiro Wada | 310 |
Patanjali's Classical Yoga: an Epistemological Emphasis Ian Whicher | 322 |