Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Sign In  |  Sign up
Your Cart (0)
Best Deals
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > Language and Literature > Reason, Revelation and Place - Evaluations of the Philosophy
Subscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Reason, Revelation and Place - Evaluations of the Philosophy
Pages from the book
Reason, Revelation and Place - Evaluations of the Philosophy
Look Inside the Book
Description
About the Book
Reason, Revelation and Peace

Professor K Satchidananda Murty, one of modern India's leading philosophers, passed away in his native village of Sangamjagarlamudi in Andhra Pradesh in 20 II. after a stellar career during the course of which he advanced knowledge rather than opinion. The Indian philosophical community, and specially Ashok Vohra, is to be congratulated for producing a book within a decade which covers Murty’s encyclopedic and dynamic engagement with philosophy. I had known Murty for more than twenty years. I interacted with him several times.

When I once asked him where he stood philosophically, he was candid enough to say that he 'oscillates between Shankar and Ramanuja'. The essays in this book amply demonstrate that he was a man of many parts but as the allusion to his mystical experiences in his The Realm of Between reveals, he was also more than the sum of his parts: that while willing to push reason rigorously to its limits, he was also willing to transcend the limits of reason when required. Thus 'revelation and reason' characterize not just the title of one of his famous books but in a sense his life and this fact renders this collection uniquely relevant for our times. I therefore enthusiastically recommend this book not only to all those interested in the philosophy of Professor Murty, or in Indian philosophy, or in philosophy in general but to all those interested in contemporary philosophizing in the broadest sense.

About the Author
Kotta Satchidananda Murty (1924-2011) Padma Shri and Padama Vibhushan awardee was one of the tallest philosopher spheres of his time. Many of his contemporaries considered him to be a 'unique', 'rare', 'dazzling', 'creative' philosopher.

He was an ingenious heterodox thinker as well as a critical traditionalist. He was a prolific writer. His writings 'are relevant to our time and its needs'. In his writings he demonstrated that philosophy does not deal with abstract and abstruse issues, rather for him the 'problems of philosophy are nothing but the problems of life'. The vast corpus of his writings contains original ideas, critical observations and insightful explanations and comparisons on themes ranging over Indian and Western Philosophy, far eastern philosophies, ethical and religious studies, social and political philosophy, peace studies, culture and tradition, philosophy of education and philosophical foundations of India's foreign policy. This volume contains critical, interpretative and constructive essays on different aspects of are writings. By evaluating ’s assumptions, starting points, normative prescriptions and conclusions, the authors of these papers point out the directions in which further research on ’s philosophy can be undertaken. The contributors comprise scholars from different universities of India who may have never met Professor Murty, or at the most have had a nodding acquaintance with him.

Foreword
Professor Kotta Satchidananda Murty is among our outstanding thinkers in the tradition of Dr. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan. His writings are extensive and his influence is felt widely. His influence goes beyond academic philosophers and his long line of students. Prof. K.S. Murty was my teacher, guide, colleague and friend. We had a very close personal and professional relationship for over sixty years. I was with him during good times and not so good times. Clearly he was the most important senior professional friend I ever had; and he was a major influence on me in many ways. I looked up to him for guidance and inspiration. He treated me as a part of his extended family. He shared my joy when success came my way; and he was there to comfort me in distress. Never did he hesitate to express his displeasure when I did not live up to his expectations. He expected the same from me. He was true friend in need as well as in deed.

That we liked each other and were very fond of each other did not mean that we were alike in our personality, habits, dispositions or philosophies we subscribe to. Indeed there were striking differences between us. Prof. Murty was bluntly outspoken and brutally sarcastic whereas I am known to be somewhat circumspect. Prof. Murty enjoyed experimenting with alcoholic 'spirits,' whereas I shy away from such adventures. I am an outdoor person, enjoying sports and such; and Prof. Murty was in some ways secluded and shut out to many worldly indulgences; even though he was passionate in some he pursued diligently. Our philosophical back- grounds and preferences were also different. He was a Vedantin in a very broad sense. I grew up in the pragmatic tradition of the Chicago school. Prof. ’s Vedanta was stained with a theistic shade and submerged in significant ways in secular waters. My pragmatism is wedded to Gandhian idealism.

There is, however, something that closely held us together. It was a spiritual bond. By spiritual I mean a state of mind, an attitude and a commitment to altruist values. The spiritual mindset is one where contraries coexist without causing conflict and discomfort. It is a state of mind beyond logic and reason. Though he shared such a spiritual orientation, Prof. Murty was rigorously rational in thinking and impeccably logical in his arguments. How- ever, rational thinking and logical argument are only to clarify ideas. They do not generate new ideas. Nor do they normally have transformational effect on the person. Creativity is deeply spiritual and is the offshoot of a different level of mental functioning. Spiritual experience is truly authentic and personally transforming to the one who has such an experience.

Spiritual for me is altruism as in Gandhi. For Murty it is some kind of a transcendental experience, which gives access to religious truth. Murty wrote,

There can be no objective, authoritative standard of religious truth ... whether a particular scripture contains a revelation or not. A man has to judge for himself whether he can realize the truth which is claimed to be revealed and embodied in a religious tradition by living in tune with that tradition, by an exercise of 'productive empathy'; and a truth not so realized and a revelation not so validated is neither truth, nor revelation for that man (195911974, p.33l).

There is every reason to think that Prof. Murty himself had some kind of transcendental experience in his own life. Many instances can be cited. It all seems to have begun at midnight on an amavasya day sitting on the shores of the Bay of Bengal, when he had the glimpses of transcendence. He wrote:

Introduction
In my first meeting with Professor K. Ramakrishna Rao, Chair- man, Indian Council of Philosophical Research, after the passing away of Professor K. Satchidananda Murty on January 24, 2011, I requested him that Indian Council of Philosophical Research should pay homage to Murty by organizing a national seminar on him. He asked me to prepare a proposal which I did promptly. He readily agreed with my proposal and promised to place it before the Research Project Committee of the Council for its approval. The Research Project Committee approved the proposal and re- quested me to organize the seminar in collaboration with Professor K.R. Rajani and Professor Y.V. Satyanarayana both of Andhra University.

It was decided to hold the seminar around September 24, 2011 - the first birthday of K. Satchidananda Murty after his passing away. The seminar was titled "The Philosophy of. Satchidananda Murty: An Evaluation." It was also decided to organize the seminar in Andhra University, Visakhapatnam where Murty had studied and taught throughout his teaching career of more than thirty-five years. Professor Satyanarayana and Professor Rajani agreed to look after the logistics of the seminar and I was entrusted the task of looking after the academic matters. However, all of us decided the names of the participants of the seminar.

The seminar was held from September 21 to 24, 2011 in Andhra University. About fifty scholars from all over India participated in the seminar. We requested the scholars to write papers on any aspect of Murty's wide range of writings which stretch across Indian and Western philosophy, covering areas as wide- spread as ethics, religious studies, social and political thought, culture, peace studies, philosophy of education, international relations, foreign policy and all the traditions - Islamic, Chinese and Japanese, in the Far Eastern region. The authors were re- quested not to limit themselves just to exegesis of ’s writings but to expound and discuss the interpretations, implicit or explicit" assumptions, starting points, beliefs, axioms, arguments, conclusions, underlying theories, under-currents of thought, normative statements and prescriptions in these works; and to evaluate them or bring out their implications, and develop them in alternative ways. We had very lively and prolonged discussions on the papers presented in the seminar. So much so that on all days the participants forgot the constraints of time and sat through late in the evenings to continue the discussions. At the end of the seminar the authors were requested to revise their papers in the light of the intense discussions they had during the seminar. This volume comprises a selection of the revised papers. Due to constraints of space, thematic relevance and other editorial constraints all the papers could not be taken up for publication. However, this in no way is a reflection on their quality.

Almost all the writings of Murty reflect that he was influenced by Vedantic theism. It is generally believed that in all his writings he presents a theistic critique of Advaita Vedanta. Ananda Mishra in his paper shows that Murty finds Advaitic conception of Nirguna Brahman untenable and attacks the doctrine of maya very much in line with the Visistadvaitins. Like the Dvaitins, Murty believes that God is God, and man is man and that a jiva can never be God. God is personal and the best way for reaching him is through personal relations. There can be nothing like eternal scripture because it will jeopardize the eternality of God. Revelation cannot be possible without a revealer and re- veiled and hence Advaitic notion of revelation is unjustifiable. Ananda Mishra challenges ’s understanding of Advaita Vedanta and presents its critique.

Like Ananda Mishra, P. R. Bhat also argues that Murty did not pay sufficiently critical attention to Advaita philosophy because he did not go beyond its received presentation and interpretation. As a consequence he offered only the expected criticisms of the system.

Book's Contents and Sample Pages











Reason, Revelation and Place - Evaluations of the Philosophy

Item Code:
NAX868
Cover:
HARDCOVER
Edition:
2020
ISBN:
9788120842755
Language:
English
Size:
9.00 X 6.00 inch
Pages:
356
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 0.54 Kg
Price:
$40.00   Shipping Free
Look Inside the Book
Be the first to rate this product
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Reason, Revelation and Place - Evaluations of the Philosophy
From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 166 times since 31st Oct, 2020
About the Book
Reason, Revelation and Peace

Professor K Satchidananda Murty, one of modern India's leading philosophers, passed away in his native village of Sangamjagarlamudi in Andhra Pradesh in 20 II. after a stellar career during the course of which he advanced knowledge rather than opinion. The Indian philosophical community, and specially Ashok Vohra, is to be congratulated for producing a book within a decade which covers Murty’s encyclopedic and dynamic engagement with philosophy. I had known Murty for more than twenty years. I interacted with him several times.

When I once asked him where he stood philosophically, he was candid enough to say that he 'oscillates between Shankar and Ramanuja'. The essays in this book amply demonstrate that he was a man of many parts but as the allusion to his mystical experiences in his The Realm of Between reveals, he was also more than the sum of his parts: that while willing to push reason rigorously to its limits, he was also willing to transcend the limits of reason when required. Thus 'revelation and reason' characterize not just the title of one of his famous books but in a sense his life and this fact renders this collection uniquely relevant for our times. I therefore enthusiastically recommend this book not only to all those interested in the philosophy of Professor Murty, or in Indian philosophy, or in philosophy in general but to all those interested in contemporary philosophizing in the broadest sense.

About the Author
Kotta Satchidananda Murty (1924-2011) Padma Shri and Padama Vibhushan awardee was one of the tallest philosopher spheres of his time. Many of his contemporaries considered him to be a 'unique', 'rare', 'dazzling', 'creative' philosopher.

He was an ingenious heterodox thinker as well as a critical traditionalist. He was a prolific writer. His writings 'are relevant to our time and its needs'. In his writings he demonstrated that philosophy does not deal with abstract and abstruse issues, rather for him the 'problems of philosophy are nothing but the problems of life'. The vast corpus of his writings contains original ideas, critical observations and insightful explanations and comparisons on themes ranging over Indian and Western Philosophy, far eastern philosophies, ethical and religious studies, social and political philosophy, peace studies, culture and tradition, philosophy of education and philosophical foundations of India's foreign policy. This volume contains critical, interpretative and constructive essays on different aspects of are writings. By evaluating ’s assumptions, starting points, normative prescriptions and conclusions, the authors of these papers point out the directions in which further research on ’s philosophy can be undertaken. The contributors comprise scholars from different universities of India who may have never met Professor Murty, or at the most have had a nodding acquaintance with him.

Foreword
Professor Kotta Satchidananda Murty is among our outstanding thinkers in the tradition of Dr. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan. His writings are extensive and his influence is felt widely. His influence goes beyond academic philosophers and his long line of students. Prof. K.S. Murty was my teacher, guide, colleague and friend. We had a very close personal and professional relationship for over sixty years. I was with him during good times and not so good times. Clearly he was the most important senior professional friend I ever had; and he was a major influence on me in many ways. I looked up to him for guidance and inspiration. He treated me as a part of his extended family. He shared my joy when success came my way; and he was there to comfort me in distress. Never did he hesitate to express his displeasure when I did not live up to his expectations. He expected the same from me. He was true friend in need as well as in deed.

That we liked each other and were very fond of each other did not mean that we were alike in our personality, habits, dispositions or philosophies we subscribe to. Indeed there were striking differences between us. Prof. Murty was bluntly outspoken and brutally sarcastic whereas I am known to be somewhat circumspect. Prof. Murty enjoyed experimenting with alcoholic 'spirits,' whereas I shy away from such adventures. I am an outdoor person, enjoying sports and such; and Prof. Murty was in some ways secluded and shut out to many worldly indulgences; even though he was passionate in some he pursued diligently. Our philosophical back- grounds and preferences were also different. He was a Vedantin in a very broad sense. I grew up in the pragmatic tradition of the Chicago school. Prof. ’s Vedanta was stained with a theistic shade and submerged in significant ways in secular waters. My pragmatism is wedded to Gandhian idealism.

There is, however, something that closely held us together. It was a spiritual bond. By spiritual I mean a state of mind, an attitude and a commitment to altruist values. The spiritual mindset is one where contraries coexist without causing conflict and discomfort. It is a state of mind beyond logic and reason. Though he shared such a spiritual orientation, Prof. Murty was rigorously rational in thinking and impeccably logical in his arguments. How- ever, rational thinking and logical argument are only to clarify ideas. They do not generate new ideas. Nor do they normally have transformational effect on the person. Creativity is deeply spiritual and is the offshoot of a different level of mental functioning. Spiritual experience is truly authentic and personally transforming to the one who has such an experience.

Spiritual for me is altruism as in Gandhi. For Murty it is some kind of a transcendental experience, which gives access to religious truth. Murty wrote,

There can be no objective, authoritative standard of religious truth ... whether a particular scripture contains a revelation or not. A man has to judge for himself whether he can realize the truth which is claimed to be revealed and embodied in a religious tradition by living in tune with that tradition, by an exercise of 'productive empathy'; and a truth not so realized and a revelation not so validated is neither truth, nor revelation for that man (195911974, p.33l).

There is every reason to think that Prof. Murty himself had some kind of transcendental experience in his own life. Many instances can be cited. It all seems to have begun at midnight on an amavasya day sitting on the shores of the Bay of Bengal, when he had the glimpses of transcendence. He wrote:

Introduction
In my first meeting with Professor K. Ramakrishna Rao, Chair- man, Indian Council of Philosophical Research, after the passing away of Professor K. Satchidananda Murty on January 24, 2011, I requested him that Indian Council of Philosophical Research should pay homage to Murty by organizing a national seminar on him. He asked me to prepare a proposal which I did promptly. He readily agreed with my proposal and promised to place it before the Research Project Committee of the Council for its approval. The Research Project Committee approved the proposal and re- quested me to organize the seminar in collaboration with Professor K.R. Rajani and Professor Y.V. Satyanarayana both of Andhra University.

It was decided to hold the seminar around September 24, 2011 - the first birthday of K. Satchidananda Murty after his passing away. The seminar was titled "The Philosophy of. Satchidananda Murty: An Evaluation." It was also decided to organize the seminar in Andhra University, Visakhapatnam where Murty had studied and taught throughout his teaching career of more than thirty-five years. Professor Satyanarayana and Professor Rajani agreed to look after the logistics of the seminar and I was entrusted the task of looking after the academic matters. However, all of us decided the names of the participants of the seminar.

The seminar was held from September 21 to 24, 2011 in Andhra University. About fifty scholars from all over India participated in the seminar. We requested the scholars to write papers on any aspect of Murty's wide range of writings which stretch across Indian and Western philosophy, covering areas as wide- spread as ethics, religious studies, social and political thought, culture, peace studies, philosophy of education, international relations, foreign policy and all the traditions - Islamic, Chinese and Japanese, in the Far Eastern region. The authors were re- quested not to limit themselves just to exegesis of ’s writings but to expound and discuss the interpretations, implicit or explicit" assumptions, starting points, beliefs, axioms, arguments, conclusions, underlying theories, under-currents of thought, normative statements and prescriptions in these works; and to evaluate them or bring out their implications, and develop them in alternative ways. We had very lively and prolonged discussions on the papers presented in the seminar. So much so that on all days the participants forgot the constraints of time and sat through late in the evenings to continue the discussions. At the end of the seminar the authors were requested to revise their papers in the light of the intense discussions they had during the seminar. This volume comprises a selection of the revised papers. Due to constraints of space, thematic relevance and other editorial constraints all the papers could not be taken up for publication. However, this in no way is a reflection on their quality.

Almost all the writings of Murty reflect that he was influenced by Vedantic theism. It is generally believed that in all his writings he presents a theistic critique of Advaita Vedanta. Ananda Mishra in his paper shows that Murty finds Advaitic conception of Nirguna Brahman untenable and attacks the doctrine of maya very much in line with the Visistadvaitins. Like the Dvaitins, Murty believes that God is God, and man is man and that a jiva can never be God. God is personal and the best way for reaching him is through personal relations. There can be nothing like eternal scripture because it will jeopardize the eternality of God. Revelation cannot be possible without a revealer and re- veiled and hence Advaitic notion of revelation is unjustifiable. Ananda Mishra challenges ’s understanding of Advaita Vedanta and presents its critique.

Like Ananda Mishra, P. R. Bhat also argues that Murty did not pay sufficiently critical attention to Advaita philosophy because he did not go beyond its received presentation and interpretation. As a consequence he offered only the expected criticisms of the system.

Book's Contents and Sample Pages











Post a Comment
 
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to Reason, Revelation and Place - Evaluations of the Philosophy (Language and Literature | Books)

Philosophical Perspectives of K. Satchidananda Murty
by Pusuluri Boaz
HARDCOVER (Edition: 2013)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: NAW046
$29.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Evolution of Indian Philosophy
Item Code: NAW009
$29.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Hinduism and Its Development
Item Code: NAV838
$29.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Hinduism and Its Development
Item Code: NAV843
$21.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Vedic Hermeneutics
Item Code: NAB478
$30.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Realm of Between (An Old and Rare Book)
Item Code: IDG546
$29.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Consciousness, Gandhi and Yoga (Interdisciplinary, East-West Odyssey of K.Ramakrishna Rao)
Deal 20% Off
by B. Sambasiva Prasad
Hardcover (Edition: 2013)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: NAF955
$82.00$65.60
You save: $16.40 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Evolution of Indian Philosophy: Andhra University Philosophical Studies, no. 8
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: IDI946
$20.00$16.00
You save: $4.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Veda and Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book)
by Ram Murti Sharma
HARDCOVER (Edition: 1996)
Eastern Book Linkers
Item Code: NAU096
$23.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Studies in Vedanta Essays in Honour of Professor S.S. Rama Rao Pappu
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: IDF169
$31.00$24.80
You save: $6.20 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
A Spectrum of Philosophical Views (Russia looks at India)
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: NAE350
$38.50$30.80
You save: $7.70 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Discourses in Buddhist Classics
Deal 20% Off
by V.V.S. Saibaba
Hardcover (Edition: 2006)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IHF048
$24.00$19.20
You save: $4.80 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Testimonials
Thank you guys! I got the book! Your relentless effort to set this order right is much appreciated!!
Utpal, USA
You guys always provide the best customer care. Thank you so much for this.
Devin, USA
On the 4th of January I received the ordered Peacock Bell Lamps in excellent condition. Thank you very much. 
Alexander, Moscow
Gracias por todo, Parvati es preciosa, ya le he recibido.
Joan Carlos, Spain
We received the item in good shape without any damage. It is simply gorgeous. Look forward to more business with you. Thank you.
Sarabjit, USA
Your sculpture is truly beautiful and of inspiring quality!  I wish you continuous great success so that you may always be able to offer such beauty to all people throughout the world! Thank you for caring about your customers as well as the standard of your products.  It is extremely appreciated!! Sending you much love.
Deborah, USA
I’m glad you guys understand my side, well you guys have one of the best international store,  And I will probably continue being pleased costumer Thank you guys so much.
Renato, Brazil
I'm always so appreciative of Exotic India. You have such a terrific website, and great customer service. I wish you all the best, and hope you have a happy new year!
Eric, USA
A Statue was ordered on Dec 22nd and Paid 194.25 including FREE DELIVERY for me as a GIFT for Christmas and they Confirmed that it will be there in 4-5 days but it NEVER arrived till 30th of December and inspite of my various emails they only replied that it is being finished and will be shipped in 24hrs but that was a LIE and no further delivery information was every sent to me. I called and left a message on the phone number listed on their website which is a NY number but no one answered that phone and I left messages but no reply or update on my Statue was sent to me inspite of my daily emails to know the status. I still await this Statue but NO RESPONSIBLE REPLY.
Rita Wason
I got my order today. It was well packed and looks lovely.
Nirmaladevi, USA
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2021 © Exotic India