Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Sign In  |  Sign up
Your Cart (0)
Best Deals
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > History > On Interpreting India's Past
Subscribe to our newsletter and discounts
On Interpreting India's Past
Pages from the book
On Interpreting India's Past
Look Inside the Book
Description
Foreword

The first Ava Maiti Memorial Lecture delivered at the Asiatic Society by Professor Amartya Sen on 20 March, 1995 was so rich and penetrating a text that it immediately aroused considerable intellectual interest, and the Society felt that it should be published as an independent title at the earliest opportunity. Professor Sen liked the idea, and sent us a revised version of the paper which now appears as an Asiatic Society publication. Professor Sen however is still afraid that it may appear to be 'slight' to some readers at least as an independent volume, and proposes to contribute it to a collection of relevant papers. But we at the Society are convinced that it will make a significant contribution to the ongoing lively debate 'on interpreting India's past'.

Professor Sen handed the revised typescript over to us on 28 December, 1995 when he received the Indira Gandhi Memorial Plaque awarded by the Society. Our production team produced a print-out in record time, and Professor Sen took time off from his busy schedule to correct the proofs in Boston, and sent them back to us, enabling us to keep to the schedule of releasing the book at the Calcutta Book Fair, 1996.

Ms Ava Maiti (1923-94) was an important activist in the country's struggle for independence, and a leading Parliamentarian in independent India, serving as a Cabinet Minister at the Centre for a spell. The Endowment provided by the Bharat Margarine Company Limited in her memory will support a series of annual lectures to be delivered by outstanding academics. The Society is proud to have had Professor Sen as the first speaker in the series.

Introduction

We live in the present, but that is a tiny bit of time - it passes as we talk. The current moment, vivid as it is, does not tell us much about who we are, how we can reasonably see ourselves, and where we would place our loyalties if and when we face divisions. Our identities are strongly influenced by the past. The self- perceptions that characterize a group are associated with, and to a great extent defined by, the shared memories and recollections of the past, and by the agreed priorities and implicit allegiances that draw on those evocations.

While this applies generally to all societies, the past becomes a particularly sharp battleground when contemporary debates invoke the past to redefine a collectivity and to allege the centrality of some particular features and the unimportance of others. This is very much the situation in India today. The tentative understandings that had become intellectually dominant during the national movement (and which had provided what was claimed to be a workable basis for the polity of the newly independent and freshly separated India) are now being subjected to severe questioning. The nationalist interpretations of 'Indianness', perhaps the most influential version of which is reflected in Jawaharlal Nehru's Discovery of India, have been bruised fairly extensively by a variety of challenges.

To dismiss these challenges as arising out of political motivations and contingencies (such as the priorities of the newly empowered Hindu politics, or the demands of communitarian confrontation) is to minimize the force, of the intellectual questioning involved in these confrontations, and to overlook the political motivation that underlies also the classical nationalist interpretation itself. In so far as some of the redefinitions that are being advanced are arbitrary and ad hoc (and governed by the immediacy of the political agenda of particular movements), these proposals might well be seen as foundationally weak. But even when this is the case, this fact would not, by itself, re-establish the intellectual standing of the classical nationalist interpretation. There is no escape from reexamining the theoretical underpinning and the cogency of the nationalist approaches, along with investigating their practical relevance and import.

The substantive purpose of this essay is to examine the nationalist interpretation of India's past and some of the challenges that have been presented to it, and to relate them to the contemporary preoccupations that are active today. I shall argue that some parts of the established nationalist conceptions survive better than others, and the vulnerabilities are not quite the ones that seem to receive the most attention. It is important to distinguish between the different aspects of the classical nationalist interpretation and to see their respective roles and congruity.

As a background to this substantive exercise, it is necessary to sort out some methodological issues involved in these interpretative programmes, and this too I shall have to attempt. The methodological issues are taken up in the next section. But before that I should make a clarificatory remark.

The limits of national identity can be compared with the identities associated respectively with (1) the more restricted boundaries of communities and groups within a nation, and (2) the more inclusive coverage of broader categories, such as the identity of being an 'Asian,' or even that of belonging to the human race. Critiques of 'nationalism' from the former - more restricted -perspective would tend to take quite different lines from those presented in the latter- more inclusive - contexts. Recent demands for reexamination of the classical conceptions of Indian national identity have mostly come from the former viewpoints (for example, emphasizing the 'fragments,' as they are sometimes called, over the 'nation'). This essay is concerned entirely with those lines of critique, and does not consider the important challenges to nationalism coming from broader identities. It is, however, worth noting that classical Indian formulations of nationalism often did emphasize the importance of broader concerns that go beyond national limits. In one form or another, references to such constraints can be very clearly seen in the writings of Gandhi, Tagore, Nehru and others. The anticolonial nationalists often had strong global commitments, while invoking the unity of the nation in pursuit of demands for 'self-determination.'

Contents

1Introduction 1
2Positional Objectivity, Epistemology and Practical Reason 4
3External Orientation and Emphasis on Difference 10
4Classical Nationalism: Diversity and National Unity 13
5The Nation and The Communities 21
6Diversity of Relevance 27
7A Concluding Remark 36

Sample Pages





On Interpreting India's Past

Deal 20% Off
Item Code:
NAN920
Cover:
Paperback
Edition:
2016
Publisher:
ISBN:
9789381574430
Language:
English
Size:
8.5 inch x 5.5 inch
Pages:
48
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 65 gms
Price:
$11.00
Discounted:
$6.60   Shipping Free
You Save:
$4.40 (20% + 25%)
Look Inside the Book
Be the first to rate this product
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
On Interpreting India's Past
From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 1420 times since 1st Mar, 2017
Foreword

The first Ava Maiti Memorial Lecture delivered at the Asiatic Society by Professor Amartya Sen on 20 March, 1995 was so rich and penetrating a text that it immediately aroused considerable intellectual interest, and the Society felt that it should be published as an independent title at the earliest opportunity. Professor Sen liked the idea, and sent us a revised version of the paper which now appears as an Asiatic Society publication. Professor Sen however is still afraid that it may appear to be 'slight' to some readers at least as an independent volume, and proposes to contribute it to a collection of relevant papers. But we at the Society are convinced that it will make a significant contribution to the ongoing lively debate 'on interpreting India's past'.

Professor Sen handed the revised typescript over to us on 28 December, 1995 when he received the Indira Gandhi Memorial Plaque awarded by the Society. Our production team produced a print-out in record time, and Professor Sen took time off from his busy schedule to correct the proofs in Boston, and sent them back to us, enabling us to keep to the schedule of releasing the book at the Calcutta Book Fair, 1996.

Ms Ava Maiti (1923-94) was an important activist in the country's struggle for independence, and a leading Parliamentarian in independent India, serving as a Cabinet Minister at the Centre for a spell. The Endowment provided by the Bharat Margarine Company Limited in her memory will support a series of annual lectures to be delivered by outstanding academics. The Society is proud to have had Professor Sen as the first speaker in the series.

Introduction

We live in the present, but that is a tiny bit of time - it passes as we talk. The current moment, vivid as it is, does not tell us much about who we are, how we can reasonably see ourselves, and where we would place our loyalties if and when we face divisions. Our identities are strongly influenced by the past. The self- perceptions that characterize a group are associated with, and to a great extent defined by, the shared memories and recollections of the past, and by the agreed priorities and implicit allegiances that draw on those evocations.

While this applies generally to all societies, the past becomes a particularly sharp battleground when contemporary debates invoke the past to redefine a collectivity and to allege the centrality of some particular features and the unimportance of others. This is very much the situation in India today. The tentative understandings that had become intellectually dominant during the national movement (and which had provided what was claimed to be a workable basis for the polity of the newly independent and freshly separated India) are now being subjected to severe questioning. The nationalist interpretations of 'Indianness', perhaps the most influential version of which is reflected in Jawaharlal Nehru's Discovery of India, have been bruised fairly extensively by a variety of challenges.

To dismiss these challenges as arising out of political motivations and contingencies (such as the priorities of the newly empowered Hindu politics, or the demands of communitarian confrontation) is to minimize the force, of the intellectual questioning involved in these confrontations, and to overlook the political motivation that underlies also the classical nationalist interpretation itself. In so far as some of the redefinitions that are being advanced are arbitrary and ad hoc (and governed by the immediacy of the political agenda of particular movements), these proposals might well be seen as foundationally weak. But even when this is the case, this fact would not, by itself, re-establish the intellectual standing of the classical nationalist interpretation. There is no escape from reexamining the theoretical underpinning and the cogency of the nationalist approaches, along with investigating their practical relevance and import.

The substantive purpose of this essay is to examine the nationalist interpretation of India's past and some of the challenges that have been presented to it, and to relate them to the contemporary preoccupations that are active today. I shall argue that some parts of the established nationalist conceptions survive better than others, and the vulnerabilities are not quite the ones that seem to receive the most attention. It is important to distinguish between the different aspects of the classical nationalist interpretation and to see their respective roles and congruity.

As a background to this substantive exercise, it is necessary to sort out some methodological issues involved in these interpretative programmes, and this too I shall have to attempt. The methodological issues are taken up in the next section. But before that I should make a clarificatory remark.

The limits of national identity can be compared with the identities associated respectively with (1) the more restricted boundaries of communities and groups within a nation, and (2) the more inclusive coverage of broader categories, such as the identity of being an 'Asian,' or even that of belonging to the human race. Critiques of 'nationalism' from the former - more restricted -perspective would tend to take quite different lines from those presented in the latter- more inclusive - contexts. Recent demands for reexamination of the classical conceptions of Indian national identity have mostly come from the former viewpoints (for example, emphasizing the 'fragments,' as they are sometimes called, over the 'nation'). This essay is concerned entirely with those lines of critique, and does not consider the important challenges to nationalism coming from broader identities. It is, however, worth noting that classical Indian formulations of nationalism often did emphasize the importance of broader concerns that go beyond national limits. In one form or another, references to such constraints can be very clearly seen in the writings of Gandhi, Tagore, Nehru and others. The anticolonial nationalists often had strong global commitments, while invoking the unity of the nation in pursuit of demands for 'self-determination.'

Contents

1Introduction 1
2Positional Objectivity, Epistemology and Practical Reason 4
3External Orientation and Emphasis on Difference 10
4Classical Nationalism: Diversity and National Unity 13
5The Nation and The Communities 21
6Diversity of Relevance 27
7A Concluding Remark 36

Sample Pages





Post a Comment
 
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to On Interpreting India's Past (History | Books)

Revealing India's Past (A Co-operative Record of Archaeological Conservation and Exploration in India and Beyond)
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: IDJ110
$39.50$23.70
You save: $15.80 (20 + 25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
India's Ancient Past
by R.S. Sharma
Paperback (Edition: 2010)
Oxford University Press, New Delhi
Item Code: IDF079
$31.00$23.25
You save: $7.75 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Across The Seven Seas (Indian Travellers's Tales From The Past)
Deal 20% Off
by Anuradha Kumar
Paperback (Edition: 2015)
Hachette India
Item Code: NAL564
$13.00$7.80
You save: $5.20 (20 + 25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Many Lives of a Rajput Queen (Heroic Pasts in India 1500-1900)
by Ramya Sreenivasan
Hardcover (Edition: 2007)
Permanent Black
Item Code: NAG002
$35.00$26.25
You save: $8.75 (25%)
SOLD
Masculinity, Asceticism, Hinduism (Past and Present Imaginings of India)
by Chandrima Chakraborty
Hardcover (Edition: 2011)
Permanent Black
Item Code: NAH135
$40.00$30.00
You save: $10.00 (25%)
SOLD
India My Love (Fragments of Golden Past)
by Osho
Hardcover (Edition: 2016)
Osho Media International
Item Code: NAM300
$52.00$39.00
You save: $13.00 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Marshalling The Past (Ancient India and Its Modern Histories)
by Nayanjot Lahiri
Paperback (Edition: 2012)
Permanent Black
Item Code: NAH313
$47.00$35.25
You save: $11.75 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Affinities: India and Korea Past and Present
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: NAH541
$47.00$28.20
You save: $18.80 (20 + 25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Creative Pasts: Historical Memory and Identity in Western India (1700-1960)
by Prachi Deshpande
Paperback (Edition: 2013)
Permanent Black
Item Code: NAH538
$28.50$21.38
You save: $7.12 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Past Before Us (Historical Traditions of Early North India)
Deal 20% Off
by Romila Thapar
Hardcover (Edition: 2013)
Permanent Black
Item Code: NAG798
$62.00$37.20
You save: $24.80 (20 + 25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Many Lives of A Rajput Queen: Heroic Pasts in India c. 1500-1900
by Ramya Sreenivasan
Hardcover (Edition: 2007)
Permanent Black
Item Code: IHG079
$41.50$31.12
You save: $10.38 (25%)
SOLD
The State in India: Past and Present
Item Code: IDF351
$36.00$27.00
You save: $9.00 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Testimonials
Thank you for really great prices compared to other sellers. I have recommended your website to over 40 of my classmates.
Kimia, USA
I am so happy to have found you!! What a wonderful source for books of Indian origin at reasonable cost! Thank you!
Urvi, USA
I very much appreciate your web site and the products you have available. I especially like the ancient cookbooks you have and am always looking for others here to share with my friends.
Sam, USA
Very good service thank you. Keep up the good work !
Charles, Switzerland
Namaste! Thank you for your kind assistance! I would like to inform that your package arrived today and all is very well. I appreciate all your support and definitively will continue ordering form your company again in the near future!
Lizette, Puerto Rico
I just wanted to thank you again, mere dost, for shipping the Nataraj. We now have it in our home, thanks to you and Exotic India. We are most grateful. Bahut dhanyavad!
Drea and Kalinidi, Ireland
I am extremely very happy to see an Indian website providing arts, crafts and books from all over India and dispatching to all over the world ! Great work, keep it going. Looking forward to more and more purchase from you. Thank you for your service.
Vrunda
We have always enjoyed your products.
Elizabeth, USA
Thank you for the prompt delivery of the bowl, which I am very satisfied with.
Frans, the Netherlands
I have received my books and they are in perfect condition. You provide excellent service to your customers, DHL too, and I thank you for that. I recommended you to my friend who is the director of the Aurobindo bookstore.
Mr. Forget from Montreal
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2020 © Exotic India